YES, IT WAS A GREAT SUPER BOWL, BUT...
- Details
- Created: 15 February 2023
YES, IT WAS A GREAT SUPER BOWL, BUT…
By
Chuck Cascio
Never Ask “Why”—Football Players’ Fight for Freedom in the NFL
https://tupress.temple.edu/books/never-ask-why
Hardcover and ebook
Most of us will agree: Super Bowl LVII was a great game! Naturally, my many dear friends who are Eagles fans will think differently (I understand!). Nonetheless, the game provided many memorable individual athletic performances (Hurts and Mahomes in particular) and societal impact signs (first Super Bowl ever featuring two Black starting quarterbacks; many players wearing notations on their helmets about social causes; clear attempts to draw attention to minorities in attendance; references to Black History Month).
But fans of this sport that attracts more attention than any other sport in America, this single game that drew approximately 113 million viewers, this unique league that grosses approximately $18 billion per year...fans of this deeply-rooted American phenomenon need to acknowledge that in order to survive, the game must evolve. And to continue to grow and adapt, NFL leaders must consistently remember the roots of the game.
Please know: I too love the game. I played it in my youth. I have followed it closely since my boyhood days in Brooklyn through my adult life in the DC area. But it is the recently published book by Temple University Press that I edited entitled Never Ask “Why”--Football Players' Fight for Freedom in the NFL, by the late Ed Garvey (head of the National Football League Players Association from 1971-1983), that has increased my awareness of the importance of football's ongoing need to adapt.
The book serves as a reminder of the struggle of race, wealth, labor, and equality in this sport, and in America. Today approximately 60% of the NFL players are Black, yet it is a sport in which owners often treated Blacks--and too often all players--with disdain.
While working on Never Ask “Why”, I remembered that I always knew that those "Whites Only" signs I saw in the South on everything from restrooms and water fountains to hotels and restaurants reflected discrimination that was prevalent throughout society. And when I covered the Washington football team for various publications in the 1970s, it was evident that the same racial animus extended into every area of the sport.
My friend, the late Brig Owens, a Washington football Ring-of-Fame player with whom I wrote the book Over the Hill to the Super Bowl--his diary of Washington’s 1972 Super Bowl season--had been an outstanding quarterback for the University of Cincinnati in the early 1960s. However, when Brig was drafted into the NFL, he was told that he could not play quarterback because he was Black; instead, he would be moved to safety because of his speed. Yes, Brig became a great safety, but his treatment when drafted exemplified the thinking in a league that discriminated against Black players in various "key" positions.
In the 1970s, when Ed Garvey led the NFLPA, players constantly battled with owners over what should seem like basic rights--salary negotiation, health insurance, pensions. However, during that time owners simply placed their power in the hands of NFL commissioner Pete Rozelle, who had control over most decisions through something called the Rozelle Rule. Under Ed’s leadership, it took strikes, lawsuits (including one in particular by all-pro player John Mackey), protests ("No Freedom, No Football" became the slogan of striking, picketing players, and their supporters), and more than a decade of often frustrating negotiations with owners to eventually reach some areas of compromise.
Today, there is a tendency to assume that football players "have it made" given the publicity around major contracts, the average salary of approximately $2.7 million, and the median salary of approximately $870,000. In addition, today’s players receive health insurance (with some limitations) and retirement (with other limitations) so it is often assumed that players are more than comfortable.
However, fans often miss that the average career of a professional football player is just a little over three years and that the extremely high salaries we hear about raise the overall average disproportionately. Also often lost in the excitement of the games, especially the super-hyped Super Bowl, is that the game is increasingly dangerous.
It is necessary for the NFL to continue to make adjustments for the safety of players, who are the actual performers and are bigger, faster, and stronger than ever. Their strength and aggressiveness often attract the most attention from fans, coaches, and media. That is all fine as long as the game adapts to these factors, but adaptation is an ongoing process.
As we reflect on this past season and await the next, let's continue to admire the physicality of the game and respect the many exciting elements of each play--the coordination, timing, speed, strength, teamwork, and fortitude that players exhibit. But let's also recognize that the players are the performers, the entertainers, the ones taking risks on every play, so the game needs constant upgrading to support them.
As Hall of Fame NFL player Judge Alan Page writes, in part, in his foreword for Ed Garvey’s book Never Ask “Why”—Football Players’ Fight for Freedom in the NFL:
“These pages show Ed’s passion and commitment to the belief that players were workers whose performance was integral to the success of the business of football and who were due appropriate compensation, health protection, a pension, and other benefits. The goal he pursued was for players to receive a fair share of the wealth they were an integral part of creating…He believed that by sharing the wealth in an equitable manner, players would become true professionals and the game itself would be better. Ed was correct…”
Yes, it was a great Super Bowl…but real fans must realize it is not all about the money we hear of so often. It is also about players having the rights they fought to attain…a fight that must continue.
Never Ask “Why”—Football Players’ Fight for Freedom in the NFL is also available in hardcover and ebook via Amazon at:
Copyright: Chuck Cascio, all rights reserved.
Thoughts? Email chuckwrites@yahoo.com